Masjid DarusSalamMasjid DarusSalam
  • Masjid
    • About Us
    • Nikah/Marriage Services
    • Daily & Jumu’ah Prayers
    • Outreach & Services
    • Special Needs Services
    • Schedule a Visit
    • Careers
    • Ask a Question
  • Seminary
    • Takmil Program for Higher Islamic Learning
    • Tahfiz Academy for Qur’an Memorization
    • The Revelatory Sciences
    • Tadris Integrated High School
    • Tadris Prep
    • Tajwid & Tarbiyah After-School Program
    • Tafhim Weekend Islamic Studies
    • Ta’lim Online Program
    • Early Childhood Program
    • Sunday School
    • Summer 2025
      • Tamhid Summer Arabic & Islamic Studies
      • Qur’an, Islamic Studies and Sports Camp
      • Tarbiya 4 Tots
    • Sister’s Fiqh & Tajweed
    • Staff
  • Tanwir Intensive
    • About the Program
    • How to Apply
    • Curriculum
    • Accommodations
    • Student Life
    • Tuition & Aid
    • Open House
    • Integrated High School
    • FAQs
  • Multimedia
    • Jumu’ah Khutbah
    • Monthly Seminar
    • Stories of Prophet
    • Qur’an Tafsir
    • Ramadan
  • Writing Blog
    • Aqidah
    • Biographies
    • Current & Contemporary Issues
    • Fiqh
    • Hadith
    • Pearls of Wisdom
    • Tafsir
    • Other/Misc.
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
    • Donate Now
    • Fortunate 1400
    • Zakat Calculator
    • Planned Giving
    • Outright Gifts
    • Donor Advised Funds / Employer Match
    • Ramadan Resources

      Du’as & Adhkar

      Zakat Calculator

      Ramadan Timetable

      2000 Quran Khatams

    • PAY YOUR ZAKAT

      “And establish Salat and discharge the Zakat, for whatever good you advance for yourselves, you will find its reward with Allah SWT. Indeed Allah SWT is all-seeing of all that you do.“ (Qur’an 2:110)

      QuickPay

      Send Chase QuickPay to: zakat@MasjidDS.org

      Direct Debit

      To setup monthly payments by direct debit, please download the following form:
      Pledge Form
      Make checks payable to DarusSalam Foundation.

  • Masjid
    • About Us
    • Nikah/Marriage Services
    • Daily & Jumu’ah Prayers
    • Outreach & Services
    • Special Needs Services
    • Schedule a Visit
    • Careers
    • Ask a Question
  • Seminary
    • Takmil Program for Higher Islamic Learning
    • Tahfiz Academy for Qur’an Memorization
    • The Revelatory Sciences
    • Tadris Integrated High School
    • Tadris Prep
    • Tajwid & Tarbiyah After-School Program
    • Tafhim Weekend Islamic Studies
    • Ta’lim Online Program
    • Early Childhood Program
    • Sunday School
    • Summer 2025
      • Tamhid Summer Arabic & Islamic Studies
      • Qur’an, Islamic Studies and Sports Camp
      • Tarbiya 4 Tots
    • Sister’s Fiqh & Tajweed
    • Staff
  • Tanwir Intensive
    • About the Program
    • How to Apply
    • Curriculum
    • Accommodations
    • Student Life
    • Tuition & Aid
    • Open House
    • Integrated High School
    • FAQs
  • Multimedia
    • Jumu’ah Khutbah
    • Monthly Seminar
    • Stories of Prophet
    • Qur’an Tafsir
    • Ramadan
  • Writing Blog
    • Aqidah
    • Biographies
    • Current & Contemporary Issues
    • Fiqh
    • Hadith
    • Pearls of Wisdom
    • Tafsir
    • Other/Misc.
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
    • Donate Now
    • Fortunate 1400
    • Zakat Calculator
    • Planned Giving
    • Outright Gifts
    • Donor Advised Funds / Employer Match

Fiqh

  • Home
  • Fiqh
  • Mufti Muhammad Taha Karaan (RA) on the Ijma’ on Tatabbu’ al-Rukhas

Mufti Muhammad Taha Karaan (RA) on the Ijma’ on Tatabbu’ al-Rukhas

  • Posted by writingblog
  • Date December 3, 2021

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

Question

as salamu alaykum,

In al-Tahbir (p. 4091), al-Mardawi al-Hanbali cites Ibn ‘Abd al-Barr on an ijma’ that tatabbu’ al-rukhas is not permissible. Then, he seems to draw the ijma’ into question by relating a view of jawaz from Abu Is-haq al-Marwazi; and then, questions that with another naql from both him and Ibn Abi Hurayrah.

Have you ever seen a naql of jawaz on tatabbu’ al-rukhas from Abu Is-haq al-Marwazi (or another authority for that matter)? Would you consider Ibn ‘Abd al-Barr’s  report of ijma’ as admissible evidence on the issue?

JazakAllah khayran.

Mufti Taha’s Answer

Wa alaykumus salam wa rahmatuLlah

The issue on which Ibn Abi Hurayrah and Abu Ishaq al-Marwazi differed was whether a person guilty of tatabbu’ al-rukhas should be declared a fasiq or not. The issue is dicussed by Ibn Hajar and Ramli, with each of them assigning a different preference. Ramli deals with it in the introduction to Nihayah and Ibn Hajar in kitab al-qada of Tuhfah, if memory serves me correctly. I would have indicated the precise places in an inscription on the last pages of the relevant volumes in the library copies.

The issue is also dealt with by Ibn al-Subki in the section on taqlid in Jam’ al-Jawami’ where he uncharacteristically makes a wrong ascription, attributing Ibn Abi Hurayrahs view to Abu Ishaq. He also deals with how this issue of tafsiq connects with jawaz. Mahalli references the discussion to Rawdah.

Ibn ‘Abd al-Barr’s citations of ijma’ have long been notorious. I recall reading in the Qawa’id of al-Maqqari a statement that exhorts caution against ahadith quoted by fuqaha such as Ghazali and ‘Abd al-Wahhab, as well as against cases of ijma’ cited by Ibn ‘Abd al-Barr, and claims of ittifaq  by Ibn Rushd.

Of interest in this regard would be Ibn al-Humam’s statement in justification of tatabbu’. He says (in kitab al-qada of Fath al-Qadir, as cited by Shah WaliyyuLlah towards the end of ‘Iqd al-Jid): “I do not know of anything in the Shari’ah which prohibits it.”

Taha

  • Share:
writingblog

Previous post

Mufti Muhammad Taha Karaan (RA) on Stoning the Jamarat, the Second Adhan on Friday, and the Sunnahs Before the Friday Prayer
December 3, 2021

Next post

Mufti Muhammad Taha Karaan's Pretensions of Postmodernism and the Hadith of Umm Waraqah
December 3, 2021

You may also like

IMG_1971 (Large)
Shāfiʿī Scholarship: Imam al-Muzanī
15 March, 2023
IMG_1971 (Large)
Shāfiʿī Scholarship: Imam al-Buwayṭī
6 March, 2023
tanwirprepbg
A Brief Biography of Khalīfah ʿUmar bin ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz
5 March, 2023

Search

Seminary Programs

  • Summer 2025
  • Tanwir 1-Year Program
  • Tahfiz Hifz Program
  • Takmil 7-Year ‘Alim Program
  • Tafhim Weekend Classes
  • Tajwid & Tarbiyah After-School Program
  • Sunday School

Masjid

  • Daily & Jumu’ah Prayers
  • Multimedia
  • Writing Blog
  • Donate

Masjid DarusSalam

630 360 2373

office@MasjidDS.org

Support

  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe

Make a Donation

"And establish Salat and discharge the Zakat, for whatever good you advance for yourselves, you will find its reward with Allah SWT. Indeed Allah SWT is all-seeing of all that you do." (Qur'an 2:110)

Zelle

Donate Via Zelle to: info@darussalamfoundation.org

Donate Online

To make one-time or monthly donations, click here

Donation Store

To sponsor an item of your choice for our expansion, visit our donation store

SEMINARY PROGRAMS

  • Summer 2025
  • Tanwir 1-Year Program
  • Tahfiz Hifz Program
  • Takmil 7-Year ‘Alim Program
  • Tafhim Weekend Classes
  • Tajwid & Tarbiyah After-School Program
  • Sunday School

Masjid DarusSalam

630 360 2373

office@MasjidDS.org

Links

  • Masjid
  • Gallery
  • FAQs

Recommended

  • Seminary
  • Student Life

Support

  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe

© 2024 Masjid DarusSalam. All Rights Reserved.